Cross stitch guides › Stranded or intarsia?
Stranded or intarsia: which does your chart need?
Both turn a chart into colored knitting, but in different ways, and a chart drawn for one is hard work in the other. This guide shows the difference, then lets real charts decide, with the numbers.
The short answer
| Stranded (Fair Isle) | Intarsia | |
|---|---|---|
| Colors in a row | Usually two, changing often | Any number, in separate areas |
| Behind the work | Floats of the color not in use | Nothing carried; a twist where colors meet |
| Fabric | Double thickness, warm, less stretchy | Single thickness, flat, drapes like plain knitting |
| Worked | Best in the round; flat is possible | Flat, back and forth |
| Yarn | Two balls at once | A small ball or bobbin for each area |
| Suits | Small repeating patterns: yokes, hats, mittens | Pictures, big shapes, letters on a sweater front or blanket |
Let the chart decide
Three numbers tell you which a chart needs: how many colors any one row uses, the longest stretch a color would be carried behind, and how many separate patches of color there are. Our knitting maker works all three out for every chart. It suggests stranded when every row has two colors or fewer and no float is longer than 15 stitches (three times the usual catching length), and intarsia otherwise. Here are two classic stranded bands and eight of our picture charts:
| Chart | Stitches × rows | Most colors in a row | Longest float | Separate areas | Suits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fair Isle peerie band (example) | 40 × 5 | 2 | 3 sts | 101 | Stranded |
| Two-color diamonds (example) | 40 × 7 | 2 | 7 sts | 17 | Stranded |
| Striped bauble | 30 × 36 | 2 | 28 sts | 12 | Intarsia |
| Zigzag bauble | 30 × 36 | 3 | 28 sts | 103 | Intarsia |
| Polka dot bauble | 30 × 36 | 3 | 28 sts | 47 | Intarsia |
| First heart | 21 × 19 | 3 | 15 sts | 12 | Intarsia |
| Nordic snowflake bauble | 37 × 43 | 4 | 35 sts | 70 | Intarsia |
| Meow cat face | 64 × 52 | 7 | 28 sts | 45 | Intarsia |
| Red rose | 27 × 36 | 5 | 21 sts | 26 | Intarsia |
| Penguin | 26 × 36 | 5 | 18 sts | 23 | Intarsia |
The two bands are textbook stranded knitting: two colors in every row and short floats: the peerie band never carries a color more than 3 stitches, and the diamonds only need a catch where a float passes 5. Picture charts are different. The striped and zigzag baubles look like classic stranded work, yet the cream background on either side of the bauble has to be carried across its whole width: those floats are far too long, so they are better in intarsia, or knitted as a rectangle without the background. Small motifs dotted over a plain ground, like the polka dots, are a third case: knit the ground and add the dots afterwards in duplicate stitch.
Stranded knitting: the essentials
- Keep floats loose. Before you change color, spread the stitches on the right needle so the float lies the full width behind them. Tight floats pucker the fabric, and loose stitches can be eased afterwards while tight ones cannot.
- Catch long floats after about 5 stitches: twist the carried yarn once around the working yarn on the back. Our charts mark every row with a float over 5 and the color to catch.
- Hold the colors the same way all through. The color carried below on the back looks slightly bolder on the front, so keep the motif color in that position; with one color in each hand, that is usually the left hand.
- Swatch in the colorwork. Stranded fabric usually knits tighter than plain stockinette, so check gauge in the pattern itself.
Intarsia: the essentials
- Wind a bobbin for each area. Our charts count the separate areas for you. Small balls (butterflies) or clothes pegs work too.
- Twist at every color change. Drop the old color and bring the new one up from underneath it, on knit and purl rows alike. Forget, and a slit opens between the areas.
- Work it flat. Each yarn waits at the edge of its area until you come back on the next row.
- Untangle as you go. Turning the work twists the bobbins together; let them hang and spin free every few rows.
Duplicate stitch for small details
For an eye, a few letters or scattered dots, it is often easier to knit the main color plain and embroider the details afterwards in duplicate stitch, which covers each knit stitch with a new stitch in the new color. It suits round projects, where intarsia is awkward.
Questions people ask
Is Fair Isle the same as stranded knitting?
Fair Isle is a traditional kind of stranded knitting from the Shetland island of that name, with two colors in a row. People often use the name for any stranded colorwork.
How long can a float be?
Most knitters catch a float once it passes about 5 stitches, about an inch; some go to 6 or 7. Catching means twisting the carried yarn once around the working yarn on the back so it is held down.
Can I knit intarsia in the round?
It is usually worked flat, because each yarn is left where its area ends and you come back to it on the next row. There are ways to do it in the round, but for small details in a round project, duplicate stitch afterwards is easier.
Why is my stranded knitting puckered?
The floats are too tight. Spread the stitches out on the right needle before you change color so the float lies the full width, and knit a swatch in the colorwork to check your gauge. In the round, some knitters turn the work inside out so the floats travel the longer way round.
How do I stop holes in intarsia?
Twist the yarns at every color change: drop the old color and bring the new one up from underneath it, on both knit and purl rows.
Try it
More guides
- How to cross stitchThe whole craft from the first stitch to the last, for complete beginners.
- Fabric count explainedWhat 14 count means, and how count changes the size of everything.
- Aida, evenweave and linenHow the three fabrics differ and which to choose.
- How to find the centerTwo reliable ways to start in the middle so the design sits straight.
- How to read a chartSymbols, keys, grid lines and arrows explained on a real chart.
- Starting and ending a threadNo knots: the loop start, the tail start and a clean finish.
- Cross stitch glossary58 terms in plain words.