Cross stitch guides › Cross stitch vs embroidery
Cross stitch vs embroidery
Embroidery is the name for all decorative stitching on fabric, and cross stitch is one branch of it. When people set the two side by side they mean counted cross stitch against freehand embroidery, the kind worked along a drawn line. Those two are different crafts to learn.
The short answer
| Cross stitch | Freehand embroidery | |
|---|---|---|
| How the design is followed | Counted from a chart, square by square | Drawn or transferred onto the fabric, then stitched over |
| Fabric | Fabric with a grid of holes: Aida, evenweave, linen | Any plain, closely woven fabric: cotton, linen, a shirt, a tote bag |
| Needle | Blunt tapestry needle, which slips into the holes | Sharp embroidery needle, which pierces the cloth |
| Stitches to learn | One, with a few helpers | Five or six to begin; hundreds exist |
| Thread | Stranded cotton, usually two strands | The same thread, from one strand to all six |
| Hoop | Optional on Aida | Needed: the fabric must be tight |
| The look | Made of small squares, like a picture made of tiles | Flowing lines, smooth fills, raised texture |
| If you go wrong | You miscounted: unpick back to the mistake | You strayed from the line: often you can stitch over it |
How the words are used
Embroidery covers every kind of decorative needlework, from a monogram on a towel to a machine-stitched logo on a cap. Within hand embroidery there are two families.
- Counted-thread embroidery places stitches by counting the threads of the fabric. Cross stitch is the best known. Blackwork, Hardanger and needlepoint are others. Our page on cross stitch and needlepoint compares those two.
- Surface embroidery, also called freehand or freestyle embroidery, places stitches wherever the design needs them, with no regard to the weave. This is what most people mean by “embroidery”, and it is what this page compares cross stitch with.
Following a chart or following a line
A cross stitch pattern is a chart. Each square stands for one stitch and each symbol for one thread color. Nothing is marked on the fabric: you find the middle, count, and stitch. The work is exact, and anyone who follows the chart gets the same picture. How to read a chart shows what the symbols and lines mean.
An embroidery pattern is a line drawing, and it has to be put on the fabric before you start. The common ways:
- Tracing. Tape the pattern to a window or a light box, lay the fabric over it and trace with a pen made for fabric, whose line washes out or fades.
- Iron-on transfer. The printed design is pressed onto the fabric with a hot iron.
- Stick-on stabilizer. The design is printed or drawn on a film that sticks to the fabric, is stitched through and washes away in water.
- Carbon paper for fabric. Used for dark cloth, where tracing through is not possible.
The drawing only tells you where to stitch. Which stitch, how long and how close together is up to you, so two people working the same embroidery pattern produce different pieces.
Fabric
Cross stitch needs a fabric you can count: one with evenly spaced holes. Aida is the usual start, with evenweave and linen for finer work. The fabric guide explains each, and fabric count explains the numbers on the label.
Embroidery wants the opposite: a smooth, closely woven cloth with no visible holes, so that a stitch can go anywhere. Plain cotton and linen are the usual choices, and clothes, napkins and bags can be embroidered as they are.
Cross stitch can still be worked on plain cloth or clothing. Waste canvas, a gridded canvas that is tacked on, stitched through and then pulled out thread by thread, lends the cloth a grid for as long as you need one.
Needles and thread
A cross stitch needle is a tapestry needle. Its tip is blunt because it never has to pierce anything: it finds the hole and slides through. Size 24 suits 14 count Aida, and finer fabric takes a finer needle. The needle and strands chart lists them all.
An embroidery needle, also sold as a crewel needle, has a sharp tip and a long eye. It has to pass between the threads of a close weave wherever the line goes. A mixed packet of sizes 3 to 9 covers most work: a larger needle for more strands, a finer one for one or two.
The thread is the same. Six-strand cotton is the standard for both, so a box of thread serves either craft. Cross stitch nearly always uses two strands. Embroidery changes the number to change the line: one strand for a fine outline, six for a bold one. Pearl cotton, a twisted thread that is not divided, is also common in embroidery.
The stitches
Cross stitch has one stitch, the X. Half, quarter and three-quarter stitches shape curves, backstitch draws outlines and lettering, and the odd French knot makes an eye or a berry. How to cross stitch teaches the X in a few minutes.
Embroidery has a large vocabulary. A beginner can do a great deal with six stitches:
- Running stitch and backstitch for lines.
- Stem stitch for curved lines, such as stalks and handwriting.
- Satin stitch for smooth filled shapes.
- Chain stitch and its single loop, the lazy daisy, for petals and leaves.
- French knot for dots and flower centers.
Backstitch and the French knot belong to both crafts, so whichever you learn first, you already know part of the other.
Hoops
For embroidery a hoop is not optional. Plain fabric puckers unless it is held tight as a drum while you stitch. For cross stitch on Aida a hoop is a matter of taste: the fabric is stiff enough to hold in the hand. Softer evenweave and linen are easier in a hoop or frame. In both crafts, take the work out of the hoop when you stop for the day, so the ring does not mark the fabric. The hoop size calculator finds the hoop that fits a design.
Which is easier?
Cross stitch is easier to begin, for plain reasons: there is one stitch, the fabric shows you where it goes, and the chart leaves no decisions. A first piece looks like the picture on the pattern.
Embroidery asks more of the hand. Stitch length, direction and tension are yours to control, and satin stitch in particular takes practice to get smooth. In return it is quicker to cover ground, more forgiving of a wandering needle, and free: you can stitch your own handwriting or a child’s drawing without charting anything.
Cross stitch has its own difficulty, which is counting. One stitch out of place shifts everything after it, and the cure is unpicking. Counting from the center and marking the chart as you go keeps mistakes small.
Turning one into the other
- A picture or drawing into cross stitch. It has to be redrawn on a grid. The pattern maker does this for a photo or a drawing: it sets the size in stitches, picks thread colors and gives you a chart to print.
- Words into cross stitch. The text generator charts any name or saying in a stitched alphabet. In embroidery the same words would be written on the fabric and worked in stem stitch or backstitch.
- A cross stitch chart into embroidery. There is little point: the squares would have to be smoothed into lines by hand. It is easier to find a line drawing of the same subject.
- Both in one piece. This is common and looks well: cross stitch for the picture, embroidery stitches on top for stems, whiskers and lettering.
Which should you try?
- You like clear instructions and a calm, repeating task: cross stitch.
- You like to draw, and to decide as you go: embroidery.
- You want to decorate clothes, bags or linens: embroidery, or cross stitch over waste canvas.
- You want lettering, samplers and pictures with crisp detail: cross stitch.
- You want a result in an evening: a small embroidery, or a small cross stitch motif. Our free patterns include designs small enough for one sitting.
- You cannot decide: buy one box of stranded cotton. It serves both, and only the fabric and the needle differ.
Mistakes that are easy to avoid
- Using a sharp needle for cross stitch. It splits the fabric threads and the thread already in the hole. Use a blunt tapestry needle.
- Using a blunt needle for embroidery. It will not pass through a close weave without a fight.
- Embroidering without a hoop. The fabric gathers under the stitches and cannot be pressed flat afterwards.
- Tracing with an ordinary pen. The line may never wash out. Use a pen made for fabric and test it on a corner.
- Buying a kit without checking the kind. “Embroidery kit” on a box can mean either craft. Look for the words “counted cross stitch”, “stamped cross stitch” or “embroidery” and check the fabric in the picture.
Questions people ask
Is cross stitch a type of embroidery?
Yes. It is a counted-thread kind of embroidery, worked in X-shaped stitches on fabric with an even grid of holes.
Can I use embroidery thread for cross stitch?
Yes. Six-strand cotton embroidery thread is the standard cross stitch thread. Separate it and use two strands on 14 count fabric.
Can I cross stitch on ordinary fabric?
Yes, with waste canvas tacked on top to give you a grid. Stitch through both layers, then dampen the canvas and pull its threads out one by one.
What is stamped cross stitch?
Cross stitch with the X marks printed on plain fabric, so there is no counting. It sits between the two crafts: the stitch of cross stitch, with the design on the cloth as in embroidery.
Is machine embroidery the same thing?
No. It is stitched by a computer-driven machine from a digital file. It shares the name and little else with hand work.
Which is more relaxing?
That depends on you. Cross stitch is repetitive and needs counting, which many people find calming. Embroidery needs fewer sums and more small decisions.
More guides
- Cross stitch vs needlepointHow the two crafts differ, and how to use one chart for both.
- How to cross stitchThe whole craft from the first stitch to the last, for complete beginners.
- Fabric count explainedWhat 14 count means, and how count changes the size of everything.
- Aida, evenweave and linenHow the three fabrics differ and which to choose.
- How to find the centerTwo reliable ways to start in the middle so the design sits straight.
- How to read a chartSymbols, keys, grid lines and arrows explained on a real chart.
- Cross stitch glossary58 terms in plain words.